Im a large fan of cleansing water. I thought that this was a great one! It really did a nice job at taking off my makeup without having an overpowering smell. I don't use anything water proof so I can't be a judge of how it takes off waterproof makeup. I think that you really do get a nice amount of product. I would repurchase this again at the same sale price. I do prefer other cleansing waters over this if paying regular price.